Skip to content

Call coaching for SDR teams: recordings, scorecards, 1:1s

How to coach SDRs from their own calls: pick recordings that teach, score them against a short scorecard, run a weekly 1:1, and measure whether it worked.

Updated 12 October 20266 min readTypeGuide
call · Kestrel Ltd · Tom Barrett4m 12s · recorded
1:38

transcript

Ricky R.Hi Tom, Ricky calling for Northgate. Do you look after the fleet contracts at Kestrel?
ProspectI do, but we renewed with our current supplier in the spring.
Ricky R.Understood. Would a 20-minute call before your next review make sense?
ProspectThursday morning works.
script Bmeeting bookedsaved on the lead
Illustrative example — sample data, not a customer screenshot.

Most SDR coaching happens in two places: a dashboard review where the rep is told their numbers are low, and an ad-hoc “can I listen in” when someone is struggling. Neither changes much. The numbers say that something is wrong. Only the calls say what.

Good call coaching is boring on purpose. Same day each week, same short scorecard, the rep’s own recordings, one thing to change.

Start from recordings, not from the dashboard

A dashboard tells you a rep booked fewer meetings this week. It cannot tell you whether they lost the prospect in the first ten seconds, never asked a question, or asked for the meeting too late. A recording and its transcript can.

Use the numbers to pick who and which client to look at. Use the calls to find why.

Pick calls that teach

Do not review random calls. Most are voicemails and short refusals and teach nothing. Pick on purpose:

A call that booked

What worked, so the rep can do it again on purpose.

A long call that did not

The conversation happened, so the gap is in the ask or the objection.

A call with a new objection

Something the team has no answer for yet.

Three calls per rep per week is enough. Transcripts make it faster: skim the text, jump to the moment that matters, then listen to that part for tone.

A short scorecard

A scorecard keeps the review about the call, not the mood. Keep it to five or six lines a rep can remember while dialling. More than that and nobody uses it.

Part of the callWhat good looks like
OpenerName, company, a reason for the call in one or two sentences
Permission or pattern breakGives the prospect a reason to keep listening
QuestionsAt least one question about their situation before pitching
ObjectionAcknowledged, answered briefly, then back to a question
The askA specific time offered, not "would you be open to a chat"
LoggingOutcome and notes on the lead before the next dial

Score each line as done, partly done or missed. Avoid 1-10 scales; nobody agrees on what a 6 means.

The weekly 1:1

A 30-minute call coaching 1:1

  1. 1

    Numbers, briefly

    Held meetings and calls for the week, per client. Two minutes.

  2. 2

    Rep picks a call

    They choose one they want help with. It shows what they notice.

  3. 3

    Lead picks a call

    One that booked or one with a clear gap, scored together.

  4. 4

    One change

    A single thing to try next week, written down.

  5. 5

    Check last week

    Did the previous change happen? Listen for it.

One change per week is the point. Five pieces of feedback produce none.

Role-play the hard part

If the same gap shows up two weeks running, practise it. Two minutes of role-play on one objection beats twenty minutes of discussion. Use the exact words the prospect used in the recording.

Turn findings into team material

When a coaching session finds a good answer to a common objection, it should not stay in the 1:1. Add it to the client’s FAQ or script so the whole roster gets it the same day. When it finds a script line that keeps failing, test a new version against the old one rather than arguing about it. See objection handling for SDRs for how to capture objections. Coaching is one step of the weekly sales enablement loop.

Measure whether coaching works

Coaching is working if the change you asked for shows up in the next recordings, and if held meetings per working hour move in the following weeks. Look per rep and per client, against the rep’s own trailing numbers. A single good week proves nothing; a trend over several does.

Do not measure coaching by sessions held. That counts effort, not effect. For which numbers to watch, see SDR KPIs worth tracking.

Common mistakes

  • Coaching from the dashboard alone. It tells you who, not what.
  • Too many notes. Pick one change.
  • Only coaching underperformers. Strong reps have calls worth sharing; they should be reviewed too.
  • Feedback that stays in the room. A good answer found in a 1:1 belongs in the playbook.

Where Dialbrew fits

In Dialbrew every call is recorded and transcribed on the lead it belongs to, next to the notes and any booking, so picking the calls to review is a few clicks. Scripts and tips live per client project, with A/B tests between script versions. And performance per rep and per client is measured against real working hours, so you can see whether a change stuck. The scorecard itself is your own: Dialbrew has no built-in call scoring.

Book a walkthrough

Put every client on one floor

A walkthrough on your own roster, clients and commission model — from an imported list to a sent invoice. Judged on your operation, not a demo dataset.

One booked meeting pays for an SDR's seat for the month.

EU-hosted · eu-central-1 · integrates the CRM, calendar and telephony you already run